SM
Sarah Mitchell, AFC® · Reviewed by James O'Brien, CFP®
Published May 12, 2026 · Last reviewed May 24, 2026 · ~1,900 words · 8 min read

Why dollars, not APR, are the right unit

Every payday-loan disclosure you'll ever see leads with the same two letters: APR — the annual percentage rate. On a 14-day loan, that number is mathematically accurate and intuitively useless. A 661% APR feels abstract; "$528 to repay a $400 loan" does not. Borrowers make the loan decision in dollars, not percentages, and the cluster's APR-first habit obscures the choice that actually matters: whether the dollar cost is worth solving the cash shortfall this way, or whether a $5 EWA fee solves it without the spiral.

Our calculator is built around that principle. The state-by-state legal-maximum is computed in dollars. The four alternative paths are computed in dollars. We show APR underneath, in muted text, as the second reference — not the headline. If you take one habit away from this tool, take this: ask any lender "what's the total dollar amount I'll repay?" and refuse to accept "look at the APR" as the answer.

How we calculate the number

For each state, we pull three things from the Quick Cash Compliance Matrix (refreshed quarterly):

  1. The legal-maximum fee per $100 borrowed. In Alabama, the cap is $17.50; in California, $17.65; in Texas, the Credit Access Business (CAB) model layers a CAB fee on top of a small lender fee, capped at ~$22.10 per $100 / 14 days in our matrix.
  2. The legal-maximum term and rollover rules. Some states cap a single loan at 30 days, others at 31; some require an Extended Payment Plan (EPP) every 12 months.
  3. The state APR ceiling, if any. Eighteen states (Colorado, Illinois, Nebraska, South Dakota, Montana, New Mexico, the District of Columbia, plus the fifteen full-ban states) cap small-dollar consumer loans at 36% APR or ban them outright. Where the cap applies, the calculator switches to a 36% APR computation regardless of the input fee.

The alternatives layer pulls from the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) PAL II rules (max 28% APR, $20 application fee, 1–12 month term), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau guidance on earned wage access, and the standard credit-card cash-advance computation (typical 30% APR + 5% fee). For employer hardship advances we assume zero interest and no fee, which is the most common employer policy.

How to interpret your number

Three rules of thumb:

  • If the dollar gap between the payday option and the cheapest alternative is under $20, speed may be worth it.
  • If the gap is between $20 and $100, the alternative is almost always the right call — unless your paycheck is genuinely tomorrow and the alternative cannot fund in time.
  • If the gap is over $100, taking the payday loan is a rational mistake only if you have no other choice. The "no other choice" set is small. Most borrowers who think they're in it have not yet asked their HR about a same-day hardship advance, their utility about a 14-day grace period, or their landlord about a 5-day rent extension. Ask first.

The four alternatives, explained

1. Payday Alternative Loan (PAL). Created by NCUA in 2010, capped at 28% APR (PAL I) or 28% APR with 1–12 month flexibility (PAL II, 2019). Available at federal credit unions to members. Median funding time: 1–3 business days. The single best path for borrowers with even a thin credit-union relationship.

2. Earned wage access (EWA). Apps like EarnIn, DailyPay, Brigit, Dave advance pay you've already earned but not yet been paid for. Typical cost: $3–$5 per advance or a $9.99 monthly subscription. Limits: usually $100–$500 per pay period. Best for: a one-time gap of one pay cycle.

3. Credit-card cash advance. Most cards offer a cash advance at the card's cash-advance APR (often 25–30%) plus a 3–5% transaction fee. No grace period — interest accrues from day one. Worst feature: the same wallet that solves the gap can deepen it if the balance isn't repaid promptly. Best feature: instant and ubiquitous.

4. Employer or nonprofit hardship advance. Underused. Many large employers offer interest-free same-day advances of $200–$1,000 against your next paycheck. United Way 211, Modest Needs, and several faith-based networks fund small emergency grants. Funding time: hours to days.

State quirks worth knowing

Texas uses a Credit Access Business (CAB) / Credit Services Organization (CSO) structure. The fee structure is layered, which is why the legal-maximum-cost number looks unusually high.

Ohio reformed in 2018 (House Bill 123). Loans must be installment (not single-payment), capped at 28% APR, with a $20 maximum monthly maintenance fee and a 60-day minimum term — a major win for borrowers, often confused with the old pre-2018 rules.

Illinois passed the Predatory Loan Prevention Act in 2021, capping all consumer loans at 36% APR. The fifteen-day grace period and one-EPP-per-year rules from the prior regime remain on the books for legacy loans.

Colorado capped at 36% APR in 2018 (Proposition 111), in line with the federal Military Lending Act's MAPR cap for service members.

Tribal lending: a small number of online lenders operate under tribal sovereignty in states where rates would otherwise be banned. Our calculator does not include tribal-rate computations. We list licensed state lenders only.

Embed this widget in your newsroom

The calculator is free to embed under our standard embed license. Copy the snippet below into your CMS. The widget is responsive, self-contained, and updates automatically when our compliance matrix refreshes — so your story stays accurate.

<iframe
  src="https://payday-loans-cash-advance.net/tools/cost-calculator/embed"
  width="100%"
  height="640"
  frameborder="0"
  loading="lazy"
  title="Quick Cash payday loan cost calculator">
</iframe>
<p><small>Calculator courtesy of <a href="https://payday-loans-cash-advance.net/tools/cost-calculator">Quick Cash</a>.</small></p>

Attribution required. No paywalls, no commercial resale, no modification of widget content. For technical questions: [email protected].

Download the data

The underlying state matrix is published as open data on the first Monday of each quarter. Direct downloads:

What this tool does not do

The calculator shows the legal-maximum cost in your state. A specific lender may offer you a rate below that ceiling, especially if your credit profile is strong or you're a returning customer. The tool also does not reflect non-rate costs (NSF fees if a payment bounces, late fees, collection fees) or the time value of the cash gap. It is a planning tool, not an offer.

Compliance note: Quick Cash is a lead-generation service, not a lender. The figures shown reflect the legal maximum a state-licensed lender could charge in your selected state. Your actual offer terms are set by the matched lender. Quick Cash does not promise approval, no credit check, or instant funding. APR ranges vary widely by lender and applicant credit profile.

FAQ

How often is the data updated?

Quarterly, on the first Monday of January, April, July, and October, against each state's official department-of-financial-institutions publications. Emergency updates (mid-quarter law changes) are pushed within 14 days of the regulator's announcement.

Why is the Texas number higher than other allowed states?

Texas's CAB/CSO structure layers a Credit Access Business fee on top of the lender's interest. The combined cost is among the highest legal-maximums in the U.S. for short-term loans.

Do banned-state visitors see anything?

Yes. Visitors from New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Massachusetts, Georgia, North Carolina, and other ban states see the calculator switch automatically to alternatives-only mode. No payday-loan option is offered.

Can the calculator factor in my credit score?

Not at this stage. We show the state legal-maximum to give every borrower a worst-case ceiling. Your real offer, after a soft credit check at apply time, may be the same or lower.

Is the embedded version different from this one?

Functionally identical. The embed strips our header and footer for cleaner integration in a third-party page, keeps Quick Cash attribution in a small footer, and lazy-loads to protect host-page performance.

Where to go next

If you want the full state-by-state breakdown beyond the calculator, the 2026 Payday Loan Cost Index ranks all 50 states by total dollar cost. If you want to apply, the See my options form takes 30 seconds. If you've already taken a loan and the repayment is hurting you, the crisis guide walks through your next 72 hours step by step. State hubs: Texas, California, Florida, Ohio, Illinois.